Full Text Available
Note: Clicking the button above will open the full text document at the original institutional repository in a new window.
Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil
The metaphors used when speaking of equity are rather colourful. One reads, amused, of the ‘burning issue', the ‘shibboleth' and the ‘sacred cow'. But these metaphors, used as they are in a discipline which tends away from the dramatic in its everyday formulations, only lend more emphasis to the gra...
Saved in:
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Other Authors: | |
| Format: | Thesis |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Department of Commercial Law
2022
|
| Subjects: | |
| Tags: |
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1867614185639116800 |
|---|---|
| access_status_str | Open Access |
| author | van Wijk, Andrew Murray |
| author2 | Hutchison, Dale |
| author_browse | Hutchison, Dale van Wijk, Andrew Murray |
| author_facet | Hutchison, Dale van Wijk, Andrew Murray |
| author_sort | van Wijk, Andrew Murray |
| collection | Thesis |
| description | The metaphors used when speaking of equity are rather colourful. One reads, amused, of the ‘burning issue', the ‘shibboleth' and the ‘sacred cow'. But these metaphors, used as they are in a discipline which tends away from the dramatic in its everyday formulations, only lend more emphasis to the gravity of the quandary. A widening gap between views on the proper method for the judicial control of contract, be it a balanced public policy or unfettered equity, caused true discordance between the Supreme Court of Appeal and the Constitutional Court, our two highest courts. In Beadica 231 CC and Others v Trustees, Oregon Trust and Others 2020 (5) SA 247 (CC) the Constitutional Court largely settled matters when it came down on the side of public policy. This no doubt caused surprise in some quarters, given its dicta in earlier cases. Nevertheless it settled the question of which legal device was to be used. Public policy is to have sole mandate and the ‘burning issue' was, apparently, doused. As to the nature of this legal device, it is a truism that the content of public policy changes with the times, but in the constitutional republic that South Africa is today the Constitution is an unassailable source of its content and values. This makes our interpretation of what it demands in the contractual context of huge import. The tension meant that instead of the cut and thrust of hard precedent, cases were largely evaluated for their tendency to reflect the increasing public facet to this most cloistered sanctum of private law. Brought back to the challenge in Beadica, this study traces in Chapters II and II something that went largely unnoticed in the shadow of the contract tectonics then on the move: the historical antecedents and theoretical underpinnings of the public interest aspect of public policy had culminated in a tension with separate legal personality. In Beadica the parties were juristic persons yet claimed the benefit of historical, substantive equality in their contractual affairs. This claim was weighed but found wanting in the Constitutional Court - but it is this ember, the implications of the corporate veil being lifted in the evaluation of equality, that represents, if not something new, then the confirmation of what some have long argued for - or suspected. Chapter IV accordingly argues that Beadica is a confirmation of the imperative of substantive equality in the contractual context, albeit that the bar has been set very high in light of the dangers. Chapter V briefly explores the adjacent legal routes by which similar outcomes could be reached before reflecting on the general historical treatment that is the bedrock of this piece. |
| format | Thesis |
| id | oai:open.uct.ac.za:11427/36353 |
| institution | University of Cape Town (South Africa) |
| language | eng |
| last_indexed | 2026-06-10T12:48:01.800Z |
| license_str | Not specified — see source repository |
| provenance_str_mv | Harvested via OAI-PMH from UCTD — University of Cape Town Open Access Repository |
| publishDate | 2022 |
| publishDateRange | 2022 |
| publishDateSort | 2022 |
| publisher | Department of Commercial Law |
| publisherStr | Department of Commercial Law |
| record_format | dspace |
| source_str | UCTD — University of Cape Town Open Access Repository |
| spelling | oai:open.uct.ac.za:11427/36353 Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil van Wijk, Andrew Murray Hutchison, Dale Commercial Law The metaphors used when speaking of equity are rather colourful. One reads, amused, of the ‘burning issue', the ‘shibboleth' and the ‘sacred cow'. But these metaphors, used as they are in a discipline which tends away from the dramatic in its everyday formulations, only lend more emphasis to the gravity of the quandary. A widening gap between views on the proper method for the judicial control of contract, be it a balanced public policy or unfettered equity, caused true discordance between the Supreme Court of Appeal and the Constitutional Court, our two highest courts. In Beadica 231 CC and Others v Trustees, Oregon Trust and Others 2020 (5) SA 247 (CC) the Constitutional Court largely settled matters when it came down on the side of public policy. This no doubt caused surprise in some quarters, given its dicta in earlier cases. Nevertheless it settled the question of which legal device was to be used. Public policy is to have sole mandate and the ‘burning issue' was, apparently, doused. As to the nature of this legal device, it is a truism that the content of public policy changes with the times, but in the constitutional republic that South Africa is today the Constitution is an unassailable source of its content and values. This makes our interpretation of what it demands in the contractual context of huge import. The tension meant that instead of the cut and thrust of hard precedent, cases were largely evaluated for their tendency to reflect the increasing public facet to this most cloistered sanctum of private law. Brought back to the challenge in Beadica, this study traces in Chapters II and II something that went largely unnoticed in the shadow of the contract tectonics then on the move: the historical antecedents and theoretical underpinnings of the public interest aspect of public policy had culminated in a tension with separate legal personality. In Beadica the parties were juristic persons yet claimed the benefit of historical, substantive equality in their contractual affairs. This claim was weighed but found wanting in the Constitutional Court - but it is this ember, the implications of the corporate veil being lifted in the evaluation of equality, that represents, if not something new, then the confirmation of what some have long argued for - or suspected. Chapter IV accordingly argues that Beadica is a confirmation of the imperative of substantive equality in the contractual context, albeit that the bar has been set very high in light of the dangers. Chapter V briefly explores the adjacent legal routes by which similar outcomes could be reached before reflecting on the general historical treatment that is the bedrock of this piece. 2022-04-13T07:54:35Z 2022-04-13T07:54:35Z 2021 2022-04-13T07:54:01Z Master Thesis Masters LLM http://hdl.handle.net/11427/36353 eng application/pdf Department of Commercial Law Faculty of Law |
| spellingShingle | Commercial Law van Wijk, Andrew Murray Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| thesis_degree_str | Master's |
| title | Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| title_full | Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| title_fullStr | Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| title_full_unstemmed | Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| title_short | Beneath the burning issue of Beadica: public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| title_sort | beneath the burning issue of beadica public policy and context astride the corporate veil |
| topic | Commercial Law |
| url | http://hdl.handle.net/11427/36353 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT vanwijkandrewmurray beneaththeburningissueofbeadicapublicpolicyandcontextastridethecorporateveil |